

All the Gendercide Books in Existence are Transphobic; Stop Defending (And Writing) Them
Mar 27, 2022
Creator
A week ago trans Twitter blew up because another gendercide book was announced where demons disappear and torture everyone with a "y" chromosome because they're "evil." (Yup, the actual premise of the book). The author insisted that trans people were dealt with in a respectful manner (despite not identifying as trans, and only hiring one trans sensitivity reader). Ana Mardoll, the author of No Man of Woman Born (which I highly recommend) obtained an advanced copy and did a play-by-play of how Sandra's depictions of trans people was definitely transphobic.
A lesbian author, Lauren Hough, took to Twitter to slander Ana and xer review (unread, it would seem) and attacked trans people reacting to it. As a result, Lambda Literary announced it would not consider Hough's book for a Lammy Award. Mainstream media like The New York Times caught wind of this and reported a cis-centered and ill-researched article about Lauren Hough "losing" a nomination she never had without interviewing a single trans person.
This educomic will explain how disappearing everyone with a "y" chromosome in a book called "The Men" is transphobic in and of itself, give a little biology tutorial, discuss some of the things Ana covered in xer review, and talk about the ridiculousness and irresponsibility of the articles that came out afterward, focusing on The New York Times (although tons of avenues participated, including The Literary Hub). Read more in the educomic.
Top comment
I watched part of the show, and was glad they included trans men in it, but yeah that book sounds fucked up. And exactly you don't know what chromosomes you have unless specifically tested! There's people that are cis and go their lives thinking that their chromosomes match, only to find out later on that they don't. Genetics and epigenetics and phenotype presentation is very complex
Recommendation for you
Recommendation
Dead City
LGBTQ+ 420.6k likes
Recommendation
Out of the Blue
Romance 2.6m likes
Recommendation
Copper eyes
BL 1m likes
Recommendation
Humor me
Slice of life 3m likes
Recommendation
Strange and Wild
Fantasy 662k likes
Recommendation
The Little Trashmaid
Comedy 720.1k likes
Feeling lucky
Random series you may like
5.5k views20 subscribers
Please log in to add a comment.
Comments (2)
See all